Economic Opportunity Mailing List Archive

["Vinay Chand" <<address removed>>]

I better send this again with a subject or it will get rejected by spam mail 
protection systems
----- Original Message ----- 
From: Vinay Chand<mailto:<address removed>> 
To: 
Sent: Monday, April 26, 2004 16:03


I find Dick's comments on extension and cooperatives unsettling, I suppose 
because they question what I am sure for many of us are basic assumptions and 
it is always good to be so challenged.

Cooperatives are often misused in developing countries so it has become a knee 
jerk reaction to write them off. However, corruption and inefficiency that has 
brought this overall conclusion is unfortunately not restricted to 
cooperatives. By this token, we would have to avoid many of the 
Governments and bureaucracies and dare I say it some aid agencies we have to 
deal with since they are just as liable to catch the disease of poverty.

Farmers have to be organised in groups if we are to help them help themselves. 
Whether it takes the form of a cooperative, a self help group or service 
company, they all face similar risks. The costs of organisation and 
administration ultimately have to be lower than additional benefits, mainly 
income, generated. That means the intervention has to result in tangible 
benefits to be justified. There are very many instances of beneficial farmer 
organisations and although they be less important in industrialised countries 
today, they nevertheless played an important role in creating wealth.

As for extension, everybody appears to be seeking ways to avoid face to face 
work with farmers whet
her it be through computers or other mass media. All this despite the fact that 
many farmers are il
literate and do not enjoy access to computers. Of course, Dick is right about 
informal learning but does it not reflect the degree of knowledge of your 
neighbours and your situation. While it is advisable to pool extension to very 
small farmers living conveniently together, my strong gut instinct 
based on experience is that in order to change things we should actively court 
one to one contact with small farmers, the key factor being that we wish to 
effect change. If the public sector cannot provide it, by all means let us 
encourage agricultural graduates and other private sector parties 
to set up agriclinics or other vehicles. The extension workers can be given 
media to enhance their own learning and can be better equipped to allow them to 
increase their productivity but in my opinion it must be conveyed to the farmer 
through personal contact.

Best wishes,

Vinay Chand
<address removed><mailto:<address removed>>

=============================================================
To send a reply to this message that goes to all list members,
make sure that you send your reply to <address removed>

To unsubscribe from this list, send an email to "<address removed>", with the 
message body:

unsubscribe economic-opportunity <your-email-address>